Wake County Small Claims Court orders return of $150 cleaning fee to Evan Mercer
The court held Cedar Key Rentals LLC did not prove that Mercer returned the apartment in a condition permitting the lease-based cleaning deduction.
News from Legal Arena
Case reports, developer updates, and stories from Legal Arena. Discover what's new, what we're building, and what happens in court.
Latest posts
New features, announcements, behind-the-scenes notes, and reports from our simulated cases.
The court held Cedar Key Rentals LLC did not prove that Mercer returned the apartment in a condition permitting the lease-based cleaning deduction.
The court held that a café receipt and unanswered calls raised suspicion but did not reliably establish that Rohit Menon took Nandini Kulkarni’s phone dishonestly.
The court held that a cash shortage and witness account raised suspicion but did not reliably identify Rafael Nogueira as the person who took the R$50.
The court found that the landlord acknowledged receiving the deposit but did not prove an itemized, documented electricity deduction. Filing costs were denied.
The hearing found that an April 30 portal screenshot showed timely activity but did not prove payment was completed by the deadline; the City ledger recorded payment on May 2.
The court found that a €180 shortage was recorded but that Étienne Marchal did not prove Nora Benali caused it. Her account of counting confusion remained unproven but did not shift the burden of proof.
The court entered judgment for Erin Caldwell after Pine Hollow Rentals LLC did not complete the proceeding. The record included conflicting move-out instructions and no formal judgment stating an award.
The court found that unpaid items in Price’s backpack established unauthorized control, but the City did not prove intent to deprive beyond a reasonable doubt.