The hearing office identified two questions: whether the City could require drainage details and whether it gave clear notice that a separate drainage sketch was required before review was paused. It held that the first issue was not disputed in substance, while Caldwell bore the burden on the fair-notice issue because he sought relief on that basis.
The office relied principally on the April 18 completeness notice and Caldwell’s submitted site plan. The notice stated that the application was incomplete and requested a drainage sketch showing anticipated runoff direction before review could continue. The site plan showed the house, proposed shed and fence line, with a note that the yard slopes toward the alley.
The hearing office accepted that the plan contained some drainage-related information. But it held that the slope note did not establish that the City had accepted the information as sufficient for drainage review. The checklist printout, which called for a site plan showing proposed work and relevant site conditions but did not mention a drainage sketch, showed broad wording but did not prevent the City from seeking further detail.
Under the supplied code provisions, permit issuance depended on the City Administrator being satisfied that proposed work conformed with applicable City requirements. The judgment also referred to completeness and stormwater-and-drainage requirements as permitting the City to seek drainage-related details where applicable.
The hearing office concluded that the record did not contain an earlier instruction requiring a separate sketch, but also did not show that Caldwell’s slope note satisfied the City’s drainage-review requirement. It found that the April 18 email sufficiently supported the City’s position that the application was incomplete.
“That is enough to support the City’s position that the application was incomplete, but not enough to prove Evan’s fair-notice claim.”