The hearing treated the April 30 portal screenshot and the City ledger as the central evidence. Park's screenshot, taken from her phone, showed a City portal page dated April 30 stating, “Renewal submitted.” The hearing found that it was evidence of timely portal activity.
However, the visible screenshot did not show a payment confirmation, receipt, amount or transaction number. It could therefore support a claim that Park submitted something before the deadline, but not that she completed a paid renewal by that date.
The City ledger listed the $180 renewal payment as received on May 2, followed by the $180 late-fee entry. Although the record did not show whether there had been earlier failed or pending payment attempts, the hearing held that this did not undermine the ledger's basic value as an agency record of the payment-receipt date.
Under the supplied City code provision, payment must accompany the return, while penalties may be waived or reduced for good cause. The hearing held that Park bore the burden of showing timely completion and entitlement to waiver, and that the absence of proof connecting the April 30 portal activity to a completed payment was decisive.
The formal judgment stated: “A good-faith attempt can support sympathy, but sympathy is not the same as proof of good cause under the record here.”
“The record does not show whether the April 30 portal activity included payment or only a submission screen.”