The court gave greatest weight to the receipt and the silent checkout video, describing them as the most reliable records in evidence. The receipt, timestamped 6:14 p.m., listed one bottled iced tea for $2.49 and did not list a phone charger; the court said this strongly supported the conclusion that the charger had not been recorded as paid.
The video showed Price placing a charger and drink near the register, tapping a card, taking a receipt and walking toward the exit. It also showed the cashier appearing to turn toward a person near the doorway. However, because the footage had no audio, the court held it could not establish what was said during the checkout or whether Price heard a warning before leaving.
The State relied on a store note stating that Price had been told before exiting that the charger was unpaid. The court found that the record did not include direct audio or a witness account confirming that Price actually received and understood such a warning.
The court also did not find the defence’s honest-mistake account proven. There was no record showing that the charger was rung up or that a cashier clearly confirmed it had been paid. Still, the court held that the defence did not bear the burden of filling the State’s evidentiary gap on notice.
It concluded that the evidence created suspicion and established nonpayment, but did not prove every required element. As the judgment stated, "the charge cannot be sustained on this record."