The record does not contain written reasons from the court. During the hearing, however, the judge's notes identified the central factual issue as whether Caldwell followed Pine Hollow's move-out instructions and whether the landlord proved that the key had not been returned.
The materials reflected conflicting instructions. Pine Hollow relied on a standard move-out sheet requiring tenants to return keys to the leasing office during business hours or use a designated drop box. Caldwell relied on a June 29 text from a number identified in her contacts as Pine Hollow Leasing stating: "If office is closed, leave keys on kitchen counter and pull door shut behind you."
The judge's notes treated the text as supporting Caldwell's account, while recognizing that Pine Hollow's rekey invoice supported its assertion that it incurred a $150 charge. The notes also said the invoice did not itself establish that Caldwell failed to return the key or explain why it was missing.
The recorded disposition ultimately rests on Pine Hollow's failure to complete the proceeding, rather than a formal written finding resolving the competing accounts of the move-out.