The court identified two central questions: whether Cedar Key’s written accounting specifically stated the basis for the cleaning deduction, and whether the landlord proved that the $340 represented a real tenant-related cleaning expense.
It held that the reference to “professional cleaning” was some accounting, but insufficiently specific on the evidence presented. The letter did not identify what condition was found, what cleaning work was performed, or why the charge was $340.
The record contained no separate invoice, cleaner identification, task list, inspection note, or description of the apartment condition requiring cleaning. Cedar Key acknowledged that its proof was limited to the deposit letter.
Bell’s evidence did not establish the apartment’s exact condition after surrender, the court said. Still, Bell’s text message to management stating that he had cleaned the kitchen and bathroom before returning the keys supported his account that he cleaned before moving out.
The court concluded that Cedar Key bore the burden to establish both the accounting and the justification for keeping the deposit money. It found that the missing detail meant the landlord had not met that burden.
“Proof of a label is not the same as proof of a specific basis.”