The court treated the self-checkout transaction log as reliable evidence that a headphone item had been scanned and that no payment or receipt was completed. It found that this was strong evidence the item was unpaid at the relevant time, but not conclusive proof of theft.
The court said the log did not show what appeared on Ward's phone or the payment terminal, and could not distinguish between a knowing taking and a failed payment attempt. It therefore had to assess whether the State had proved the required culpable mental state, rather than merely non-payment.
Jordan Pike, a kiosk employee, supported the State's account that Ward moved away from the checkout area with the item and later said that his phone “must not have gone through.” But Pike could not say whether the terminal had displayed an error before Ward walked away, which the court said limited the evidence on Ward's knowledge.
Ward's payment-error account was not independently verified, the court noted, but it was internally consistent. He said he tapped to pay, saw an unclear error, placed the headphones in his tote while carrying coffee, and moved toward the service counter for assistance.
The court also found an unresolved factual conflict over whether Ward crossed a painted exit line. Pike said he did; Ward denied moving toward an exit with an intent to steal and said he was headed to the service counter. No independent evidence resolved that dispute.
The court concluded that the State's interpretation of Ward's post-stop statement was possible, but so was the defence account that Ward had already attempted payment and was repeating the problem after being stopped. “Unpaid status alone is not the same as theft,” the court held.
The record supports competing inferences, and the State has not carried the burden of resolving them in its favor.