The court found that Bentancur had established payment and receipt of the deposit through Sosa's WhatsApp message stating: “Received the 18,000 deposit. Keep this chat as proof.” The judgment treated that contemporaneous message as direct written acknowledgment of the deposit.
A later WhatsApp exchange showed that, after the move-out inspection, Sosa said the apartment was okay but that he needed to check the light account. The court held that this exchange showed only that a utility issue was under consideration; it did not establish the amount of any debt, the date of a bill, or that a deduction had been calculated and communicated.
Sosa's account was that the deposit had been applied to an unpaid UTE electricity balance tied to the studio. But the court found no final bill, itemized breakdown, dates, or clear calculation in the record. It held that Sosa, as the party relying on the deduction or setoff, had not proved a lawful basis to retain any part of the deposit.
The court said the result did not determine that no utility issue existed. Rather, it found that the record did not prove the amount, timing, or legitimacy of a deduction from the deposit. It therefore concluded that the full amount remained refundable.
“The case turns on proof, not suspicion.”