Kulkarni submitted that Menon picked up her smartphone from the counter at Copper Bean Café in Indiranagar, left with it, and failed to answer repeated calls for more than 20 minutes. She argued that the delay, together with the receipt placing him at the counter, supported an inference that the incident was not an innocent mix-up.
Her side acknowledged that it had no video footage or separate eyewitness identifying the particular phone in Menon’s possession. It asked the court to rely on the sequence of events and the alleged unexplained delay.
Menon disputed theft and said he had mistakenly picked up a similar black phone from the counter while paying. He referred to a WhatsApp message about returning the phone, said he did not use its password or attempt to sell or hide it, and maintained that he returned after realising the error.
Menon also referred to café staff who could support his account of returning to the café. The court noted, however, that the hearing record did not provide a clear, reliable timeline establishing when the phone was returned.