The court treated the signed lease clause as the strongest written evidence. It established that Cedar Key could deduct $150 if the apartment was not returned in reasonably clean condition, but the clause did not itself establish that the deduction was justified in this instance.
Mercer relied on his account that he cleaned before returning the keys and on photographs taken on move-out day. The court found that the materials were not complete proof of every part of the apartment, but were direct evidence supporting his account of the unit's condition at move-out.
Cedar Key argued that the photographs did not show every area, particularly the inside of the oven. The court held that this created uncertainty but did not prove that the apartment was not reasonably clean. Cedar Key did not identify a specific dirty condition with sufficient detail, and acknowledged that its invoice did not itemise the cleaning tasks.
The court gave weight to the absence of a detailed invoice or room-by-room account of the work said to be necessary. It concluded that Cedar Key had not carried the burden of proving the contractual condition for retaining the fee. As the judgment stated, “The remaining gap is not a reason to keep the money; it is a reason to find the charge unproven.”
The court also found that Mercer had sufficiently supported his refund claim through the lease language and move-out photographs. It did not award any amount beyond $150 because no larger amount was proved.
“A landlord may not keep a cleaning fee merely by saying the photos are incomplete; it must point to reliable facts showing the condition that triggered the fee.”