Gqeberha court acquits woman of drill theft after disputed nod leaves permission uncertain
A nod at a busy counter and a later message about returning the drill left the court unable to determine whether permission had been given.
Blog category
Reported verdicts, settlements, signed judgments, and arguments from Legal Arena cases.
Most recent articles
A nod at a busy counter and a later message about returning the drill left the court unable to determine whether permission had been given.
The landlord said the oven needed cleaning but acknowledged he had not checked it. The judge found insufficient proof that it was dirty.
Messages established a Saturday appointment, but not an absolute deadline. The court said the evidence did not show what happened afterward or support a refund amount.
A message saying “Go ahead” followed a label image and an undisputed question about quantity. The court found it ambiguous and said the $450 charge lacked supporting evidence.
A disputed account of concealment supported the City’s case, while a call log lent limited support to the defense. Neither resolved why the notebook left the shop unpaid.
A photo showed a dent near the kettle’s base, but the record does not establish when it occurred or what caused the leak.
A purchase receipt established who bought the bicycle, but not whether it was later lent or given away. The underlying messages were not available as separate exhibits.
The invoice established the R2,400 price, but it did not record the agreed colour. The court said one market's use did not, by itself, settle the complaint.
The spouses disagreed over whether the transfer was a loan or a contribution. A repayment message did not identify the expense, and Daniel could not substantiate his alternative explanation.
A photo described by both sides showed a sign after the fall, but was not an exhibit. Receipts documented A$200 in expenses without establishing that the fall caused a wrist injury.
The payment depends on whether supporting documents substantiate the full cleaning charge. The agreement contains no admission of liability and releases only the cleaning-deduction claim.
The dispute turned on a missing signed attendance sheet. The agreement provides for a records exchange and limits the release to the April 2025 wage claim.
Other categories