NSW Local Court dismisses café fall claim over uncertain warning sign and injury evidence
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
A photo described by both sides showed a sign after the fall, but was not an exhibit. Receipts documented A$200 in expenses without establishing that the fall caused a wrist injury.
The decision
The Local Court of New South Wales has dismissed Leah Mercer’s A$1,200 claim against Daniel Keane over a fall at a café, awarding her no compensation.
Mercer said she slipped on water tracked inside during rain and had not seen a warning sign. Keane said he had put out a yellow wet-floor sign before she arrived. The court could not determine when the sign was placed and found that Mercer had not proved the fall caused a wrist injury.
