District Court orders return of $300 cleaning deduction over uninspected oven
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
The landlord said the oven needed cleaning but acknowledged he had not checked it. The judge found insufficient proof that it was dirty.
Judgment by Mason · Presiding judge · District Court
Plaintiff: Leah Mercer · Defendant: Owen Bell
The decision
District Court Judge Mason ordered Owen Bell to pay Leah Mercer $300, the amount she sought after he withheld it from her security deposit for cleaning her Portland apartment.
The dispute turned on whether an oven needed cleaning after Mercer moved out. Mason found insufficient proof that it was dirty.
