District Court imposes death penalty and orders payment in rental deposit dispute
The dispute concerned ₹8,000 withheld for repainting. Neither party had photographs of the wall, and the painter’s receipt did not describe its earlier condition.
Blog category
Legal Arena reports about tenancy.
Most recent articles
The dispute concerned ₹8,000 withheld for repainting. Neither party had photographs of the wall, and the painter’s receipt did not describe its earlier condition.
The landlord relied on an estimate for unfinished work but said he had no receipts showing what he paid. The judgment also held him in contempt.
The landlord estimated a tenant’s share of a combined repair invoice but could not identify the exact cost for her apartment. The judge also found her account of pre-existing damage unconfirmed.
The landlord said the oven needed cleaning but acknowledged he had not checked it. The judge found insufficient proof that it was dirty.
The landlord had an invoice for repainting but no proof that the bedroom wall was unmarked before the tenancy. The tenant said her move-in photo showed the mark.
The judgment gives no reasons for its orders or decision on the disputed $300 carpet-cleaning deduction.
Neither party had a photograph of the carpet from before the tenancy. Their later images showed a mark or patch but did not capture the whole carpet.
The landlord's receipt showed a $250 cleaning charge but did not document the carpet's condition. The tenant's move-out photo did not show the area behind the bedroom door.
The tenant sought her $1,600 deposit and a $240 plumbing payment. The signed judgment records a finding of guilt but does not explain it or specify relief.
Neither party had photographs showing the wall at move-in. The judgment criticised the landlord’s lack of proof but left the tenant’s request for repayment without an express order.
The landlord’s receipt showed repainting costs, while photographs did not establish when marks appeared. The judge nevertheless found damage and imposed an additional 1,000 AFN fine.
A painter’s invoice recorded the cost but not who caused the wall marks. The tenant’s move-in photograph showed some marks already existed, though it did not capture the whole wall.