Portland small claims court denies $450 claim for second batch of candle labels
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
A message saying “Go ahead” followed a label image and an undisputed question about quantity. The court found it ambiguous and said the $450 charge lacked supporting evidence.
The decision
A small claims court in Portland denied Nora Bell's request for $450 from Eli Mercer for a second batch of labels for his candle business. The court ordered no payment and granted no other relief.
The dispute turned on what Mercer meant when he replied, “Those look good. Go ahead,” after Bell sent a label image. Bell said she understood the message as permission to print another batch; Mercer said he understood it as approval of the design or preparation.
