Cape Town Small Claims Court awards full banner price despite colour complaint
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
The invoice established the R2,400 price, but it did not record the agreed colour. The court said one market's use did not, by itself, settle the complaint.
The decision
The Cape Town Small Claims Court ordered Pieter de Villiers to pay Lebo Maseko the full R2,400 price of a shop banner, rejecting his request for a R1,200 reduction over its colour.
The dispute turned on a gap between the price recorded on the invoice and the colour the parties said had been discussed. The court did not decide that the banner matched an agreed colour; it found that de Villiers had not proved a basis for reducing the price.
