Cork District Court dismisses theft charge over unpaid drill taken outside shop
A call log supported a call near the exit, but neither it nor silent footage established intent. The court said the unpaid exit raised suspicion without proving theft.
Blog category
Reported verdicts, settlements, signed judgments, and arguments from Legal Arena cases.
Most recent articles
A call log supported a call near the exit, but neither it nor silent footage established intent. The court said the unpaid exit raised suspicion without proving theft.
The signed design agreement made delivery the trigger for payment, but no copy or message confirmed that the corrected menu reached the customer.
A message exchange confirmed the umbrella’s return, but did not establish what Eirik Solheim knew when he took it. The court found the prosecution had not proved he knew it belonged to someone else.
A move-out photo did not show the oven, while the landlord's payment record did not explain what the cleaner did. The recorded judgment gives no findings on either point.
A photo showed work on the shelf, but messages did not establish that the buyer accepted a later delivery date. The court also lacked a valuation for the unfinished work.
An incident note established the unpaid exit, while a phone log showed a call shortly beforehand. Neither resolved what Evan Mercer knew when he left, the court found.
The parties disputed whether a delivery-fee error prevented acceptance. The court denied a $9,000 delay claim for insufficient evidence.
A shop note corroborated the reported fault, while follow-up messages showed that replacement stock still had to be checked. The kettle was not independently tested.
A pre-pickup text supported a temporary loan, but the purchase receipt did not establish the ladder’s current value.
A repair ticket explained the visit, but did not identify the phone taken. A written account and the accused’s explanation conflicted over permission.
A receipt confirmed payment and café delivery, while a note showed the cards were ready. Neither established what happened to them.
Both sides agreed the wages were earned, but disputed whether cash changed hands. The court found neither account conclusively corroborated and made no finding that payment occurred.
Other categories