The strongest evidence of the arrangement was a dated text sent before pickup. Bell told Reed he could keep the ladder for now but that she would need it again to clean the gutters; Reed replied, “Okay, thanks.”
The court said the message expressly limited the arrangement and explained why Bell expected to use the ladder again. Reed’s reply did not expressly confirm a loan, but it was consistent with the message and did not say Bell was giving up ownership.
The text did not record the later in-person conversation, and the court acknowledged uncertainty about what was said at pickup. Bell’s account of that conversation came through a saved client answer relayed by counsel, not independently verified testimony. Reed had no independent evidence confirming a gift.
A later exchange showed Bell asking for the ladder back and Reed saying he thought she had given it to him. The court said that exchange recorded their disagreement, not the original words at pickup, and did not by itself prove Reed knowingly kept borrowed property.
The receipt established that Bell bought the ladder for $120, but it did not show its present condition or value. With no evidence of its age, condition, repair cost or current market value, the court found that return of the ladder—not a $120 payment—was the supported remedy.