The State’s principal evidence was a written account saying Bendre took a customer’s phone without asking. The court gave it some weight, but said it did not describe the exchange at the counter, explain how the writer knew permission had not been given, or provide identifying details for the phone.
A repair collection ticket showed that a phone was ready in Bendre’s sister’s name that day. It supported his reason for visiting, but did not establish which phone he carried away or whether he had permission to take it.
Bendre’s account, relayed through counsel, was not independent testimony or conclusive proof of permission. It nevertheless offered a specific alternative explanation that the State’s evidence did not resolve. The court said the burden remained on the State; Bendre did not have to prove his innocence or establish that permission was given.
His admission that he left with the wrong phone without checking the ticket supported the conclusion that he took a phone and failed to verify it. It did not independently identify the phone as the customer’s or establish that he intended to take it without permission.