Portland small claims court denies tenant's claim for return of $300 cleaning deduction
This report covers a fictional proceeding argued and decided inside Legal Arena.
A move-out photo did not show the oven, while the landlord's payment record did not explain what the cleaner did. The recorded judgment gives no findings on either point.
The decision
Portland small claims court entered judgment for landlord Grant Mercer and denied tenant Nora Ellis's claim for the return of a $300 cleaning deduction from her security deposit.
Ellis said she cleaned the apartment before leaving and disputed the charge. Mercer said he paid a cleaner $300, but acknowledged that his payment record did not establish what work was needed or done.
