The court accepted that the receipt proved the purchase and price, not the defect. The shop's complaint note recorded Kováčová's report that the kettle did not switch off, her refund request and a discussion about replacement; it was not a test result.
Even without independent testing or admitted witness testimony about the kettle's operation, the court found the defect established for this dispute. It relied on Kováčová's specific account, relayed by counsel, and the prompt shop record corroborating that she reported the same fault. The seller's lack of contrary evidence was not, by itself, proof of her claim.
The replacement evidence also had limits. In messages the day after the shop visit, Kováčová asked when a replacement would be available and the shop said it would check stock and respond. No later reply appeared in the thread.
The court found that the exchange did not prove a replacement could never have been obtained, but it showed no definite answer had been given in that exchange. The seller had no independent proof that a workable replacement was available or clearly offered, so the court did not find that Kováčová had rejected a fair opportunity to receive one.
Because automatic shut-off was central to the kettle's safe use, the court considered a refund of the proven purchase price proportionate. It awarded no additional monetary relief.