Back to case report
Original in-game verdict
Bratislava district court awards €45 refund for kettle that failed to switch off
This decision was delivered in a fictional Legal Arena proceeding. It is not a real court judgment or legal advice.
Client satisfaction
Satisfaction was not recorded for this historical judgment.
Background
1. Zuzana Kováčová, the plaintiff, seeks a refund of €45 from Domček Elektro, s.r.o., the defendant, for an electric kettle. She says the kettle failed to switch off automatically after boiling and that she reported the problem to the shop. The defendant does not claim that the kettle worked correctly. It asks the court to weigh the limits of the evidence and not award more than the purchase price.
2. The record includes a purchase receipt, the shop’s complaint note, and a follow-up message thread. It also includes accounts relayed by counsel from the plaintiff. Those accounts are relevant but are not independent documents or admitted witness testimony. The court decides the case on the supplied record and does not assume that the kettle was independently tested.
Issues for determination
3. The issues are whether the plaintiff proved the purchase and reported defect, and whether the evidence supports a refund rather than leaving the matter to a possible replacement. Under the supplied burden-of-proof rule, the plaintiff must support the facts needed for the relief requested. The supplied reliable-records rule gives weight to records while requiring attention to what each record actually establishes. The repair-opportunity and proportional-remedy rules require consideration of whether a fair chance to fix the problem existed and whether the requested remedy matches the proven harm.
Submissions of the parties
4. The plaintiff submits that the kettle failed to switch off on its first use, creating a safety concern. She relies on the receipt, the kettle she says she brought to court, the shop note recording the complaint, and the next-day messages about a replacement. She asks for the €45 purchase price back.
5. The defendant submits that no shop employee is identified as having tested the kettle or personally observed its operation. It accepts that its note records the customer’s report, a replacement discussion, and the refund request. It also accepts that the note does not prove a replacement was ready or clearly offered. The defendant asks the court to give the note only its limited weight and, if it does not reject the refund request, to award no more than €45.
Evidence and findings
6. The receipt is clear evidence that the plaintiff bought a kettle from the defendant for €45 four days before the complaint. It does not prove a defect. The shop note is an available record from the seller. Its wording—“Customer reports kettle does not switch off; replacement discussed; customer requests refund”—proves that the complaint and refund request were recorded and that replacement was discussed. It does not prove that a shop employee tested the kettle, that the kettle worked, or that a replacement was available.
7. The plaintiff’s relayed account is specific: the kettle kept boiling instead of switching off when first used. The shop note, made in connection with the complaint, corroborates that the same fault was reported. The defendant confirms that the note is not a test result and offers no contrary observation. The court recognizes that the plaintiff’s account is not independent testimony and that no independent test is in the record. Even so, the specific account, its consistency with the prompt shop record, and the absence of any contrary evidence establish the reported defect on the balance of this record.
8. The follow-up message thread is a dated exchange the day after the shop visit. The plaintiff asked when a replacement would be available; the shop replied that it would check stock and let her know. No later reply appears in the thread. The thread does not establish every detail of the in-person conversation or prove that no replacement could ever have been obtained. It does establish that, the next day, availability remained to be checked and the shop had not yet given the plaintiff a definite answer in that exchange. The defendant expressly acknowledges that it has no independent proof of available stock or a clear offer.
Reasons
9. On the purchase-and-defect issue, the plaintiff bears the burden. The receipt establishes the purchase and price, while the shop note corroborates the timely report of the precise fault described in the plaintiff’s account. The defendant correctly points out that neither the note nor receipt is a technical test. But the court does not treat the note as proof that the kettle was tested or as conclusive proof of the defect. Rather, the note’s contemporaneous record of the complaint supports the plaintiff’s specific account. Taken together, this evidence is sufficient to establish the defect for this dispute. The defendant’s lack of independent proof is not itself proof for the plaintiff; the finding rests on the plaintiff’s account and its corroboration in the shop record.
10. On the remedy, the plaintiff also bears the burden of showing that the requested refund is supported. The shop note proves only that replacement was discussed, not that a usable replacement was ready or clearly offered. The next-day message is more specific: the shop still needed to check stock and promised to let the plaintiff know, with no later reply shown. The defendant accepts that it cannot establish a workable replacement was available or that the plaintiff refused one. The court therefore does not find that the plaintiff rejected a fair, definite opportunity to receive a replacement.
11. The repair-opportunity rule makes a genuine chance to correct a product problem relevant. Here, the record shows discussion and an unresolved stock check, not a completed offer or correction. The defect found concerns the kettle’s automatic shut-off, a function central to its safe use. In these circumstances, a refund of the proven €45 price is proportionate under the supplied remedy rule. The award is limited to that amount: the plaintiff has not requested or proved any additional monetary loss, and none is awarded.
Final order
12. Judgment is entered for the plaintiff, Zuzana Kováčová. The defendant, Domček Elektro, s.r.o., must pay the plaintiff €45 as a refund of the kettle’s purchase price. No additional relief is awarded. This order rests on the evidence in this record, including the receipt, the shop note, and the follow-up message thread; it does not treat the kettle as having been independently tested or decide any matter beyond the refund claim.
