Garner sought the remaining $300 on the basis that the parties had agreed to a $600 fee, with half payable upfront and half on final delivery. She relied on the accepted quote and the email exchange showing that Mercer approved the preview before she emailed the final PDF.
Garner did not ask the court to treat approval of the menu’s appearance as proof of technical quality. Her submissions acknowledged that print readiness was part of the promised work and that the printer’s message did not establish whether the final PDF worked.
Mercer sought denial or reduction of the balance, maintaining that he had approved the menu’s appearance rather than its readiness for printing. His representative argued that the supplied final copy was too low-resolution and that the promised product had not been delivered.
The court’s recorded response distinguished that assertion from the available evidence. The printer had identified menu_preview.jpg as too low-resolution and requested the original PDF, rather than reporting a failure of menu_final.pdf. Mercer’s own account also acknowledged that he did not know whether the printer had tested the final file.