The judgment distinguished proof of removal from proof of a knowingly unauthorized taking. The witness’s observation and Nina’s account established that Mercer carried the drill out, but did not establish what he understood about the scope of permission.
The complete phone exchange was central to that distinction. Mercer’s request identified shelves at his apartment as the proposed project, while Nina’s reply allowed weekend use without stating that the drill had to remain at the shop. The court gave weight to that context, noting that the record established no separate authenticity challenge.
Nina’s account supported her position that she intended to allow shop-only use. However, that restriction was not expressed in her reply, and she did not speak to Mercer as he left. Her intended limit did not, without more, establish that he knew of it.
The court also considered the State’s argument that Mercer never expressly asked to take the drill home. It found that omission relevant but insufficient to resolve the ambiguity, given the express reference to an apartment project.
Applying the supplied Rule 41, which required reliable evidence for every required element, and Rule 8, which distinguished suspicion from proof, the court found the knowledge element unproven. It did not treat the defense’s assertion about Mercer’s understanding as admitted testimony or independent proof.
The court stated: “But proof that Evan removed the drill does not, by itself, prove that he knew he lacked permission to do so.”