The prosecution relied on Keane's signed account that he had told Mercer to wait before taking the sander. It argued that Mercer took the tool despite that instruction and sought a conviction for theft.
Mercer disputed that taking the sander established dishonesty. He relied on the screenshot showing his request to borrow a tool for a weekend job and Keane's response allowing borrowing, with return expected on Monday.
Mercer accepted that a further message followed and that he read it as an instruction to wait. His submission was that the available record did not resolve whether that instruction concerned the sander or a drill, leaving uncertainty about his understanding of the permission.
The recorded bench observations identified Mercer's honest belief as the key question and emphasised that the prosecution bore the burden of proving the allegation. Keane's account supported what Keane intended, while the screenshot supported Mercer's account of general permission but omitted the later qualification. These observations were not a final finding on guilt.