Bell's acceptance that he took the drill, together with shop camera footage showing him carrying its case out at Friday closing time, established the removal. However, the clip had no audio and could not establish what had been said about borrowing equipment or what Bell understood.
The court noted that the footage showed Bell carrying the case openly. That did not prove an honest belief in permission. Repeated presentations of the same clip also did not amount to separate, independent recordings.
The central gap concerned the earlier conversation. The prosecution maintained that permission extended only to a ladder, but its witness, Mara Ellison, said she had not personally observed the events and could not say what permission was given. No testimony from the shop owner or written record of the conversation supported the prosecution's assertion.
Bell's account was likewise not independently corroborated. The court nevertheless held that he did not have to prove permission: the burden remained on the prosecution to establish the charge, including the disputed criminal intent.
Applying the supplied rules requiring evidence for each element and distinguishing suspicion from proof, the court found that arguments about the drill's value, the ladder and return after police contact did not resolve Bell's understanding. The judgment addressed that central dispute without supplying a more detailed definition of theft.
“This conclusion is based on the failure of proof, not a finding that Aaron's account is true,” the court stated.