The decisive issue was Mercer's understanding of a proposed exchange involving the drill and his final pay. Under the supplied rules, the State had to support every required part of its criminal claim with reliable evidence; Mercer did not have to prove that an agreement was completed or establish an innocent explanation.
The saved messages showed Leah proposing to put the drill against $180 of Mercer's last pay and asking him to speak with her before leaving. Mercer replied that he would pick it up after his shift. No further reply appeared. The court found that this supported the State's position that the exchange was not expressly finalized, but also connected the drill to Mercer's pay without resolving what he believed.
Leah's account said she neither approved the exchange nor spoke with Mercer before he left. The court treated that as direct evidence of her own actions and understanding. Client answers relayed by counsel repeated her account, but were not independent documents or admitted witness testimony and did not provide separate corroboration.
The request to speak before leaving weighed against Mercer. However, the message did not expressly prohibit taking the drill before an agreement, and the court found no proof that he understood it as such a prohibition.
The camera image supported the finding that Mercer carried the drill out. Witness Mara Voss could not establish whether she had personally reviewed or authenticated that image, or its timing. With no audio and Leah absent from the image, it could not establish permission or Mercer's state of mind.
The court rejected the State's attempt to treat the defence's acknowledgment that the messages did not prove permission as a concession of knowing misconduct. Uncertainty about whether Mercer knowingly took an unauthorized item or misunderstood a proposed pay exchange remained unresolved.
“The defendant's concession that permission is not established by the messages does not concede that Evan knew he lacked permission.”