The court treated the $600 payment and the text exchange linking it to an anticipated Saturday start as support for Holt’s repayment request under Rule 1, which requires specific facts, records or testimony to support relief. No witness testimony was admitted.
Applying Rule 38, which requires disclosure of an important fee before a customer commits, the court found no agreement that the deposit was nonrefundable or could be retained for cancellation. Bell’s later description of the payment as compensation for a reserved slot did not establish prior disclosure.
Bell’s contention that Saturday was only an estimated start date did not resolve the separate question of whether she could keep the payment. The court did not decide that rain could never justify delay or that Bell necessarily refused to perform.
The court considered Bell’s account of rain, rescheduling and cancellation as a competing explanation for why work did not proceed. However, no admitted testimony or additional documentary detail established the precise circumstances or terms of the rescheduling offer.
Rule 6 required a remedy proportionate to proven harm. No records, testimony or quantified losses supported Bell’s claim that she turned away other clients, and no itemized material cost was established. The court therefore had no reliable basis to allow a deduction.
“Calling the payment a deposit does not, by itself, establish that the customer agreed it could be kept in full if the project did not proceed.”