On the rent deduction, the court found that Whitcomb vacated the premises on April 30 and that Mercer retained his own key. Mercer identified no evidence that she continued to occupy, use or control the premises after that date.
The lease did not expressly provide that rent would continue solely because a key remained outstanding. Mercer also acknowledged permitting a later key return without telling Whitcomb that additional rent would accrue. Those circumstances did not establish that the $400 represented unpaid rent.
The repair dispute required the court to distinguish the admitted shelf-anchor holes from the broader painting work. Whitcomb acknowledged leaving several holes without repairing them, but the contractor’s invoice grouped patching, surface preparation and repainting into a single $950 charge.
Mercer could not establish the portion attributable to the holes. The court also noted that repainting the entire living room was his decision, not a contractor’s recommendation or assessment, and that he could not establish a material difference between the paint mismatch in his May 1 photographs and the preexisting condition documented in Whitcomb’s dated move-in photograph.
The court therefore found that Mercer had not established the reasonableness and proper amount of the repair deduction attributable to Whitcomb’s conduct.