The receipt and printed return policy established a $120 purchase, a 14-day return period and a requirement that all parts be included for a refund. Both parties accepted that Schultz returned the box six days after purchase. The court found the return timely, but held that meeting the deadline did not establish compliance with the separate all-parts condition.
Applying the recorded Rule 1, the court placed the burden of proof—the obligation to support the request with specific facts, records or testimony—on Schultz. Rule 2 favored reliable records over vague accounts, while Rule 37 required enforcement of the seller’s specific consumer promise, including its stated condition.
Schultz acknowledged that she had not checked the hardware and could not say anyone else checked it at handoff. Her statements established the limits of her knowledge, not that the kit was complete. Repeated copies of the receipt and policy were not treated as separate corroboration.
The retailer’s evidence also left a gap. Its assertion that the product normally included mounting hardware did not establish the contents of this particular box. Its explanation that returns were not normally photographed explained the absence of a photograph but did not prove missing parts.
The court declined to infer either completeness or incompleteness from the absence of photographs. It also declined an adjournment, recording that the hearing had reached closing, adjournment was not allowed and Schultz had no further evidence to resolve the uncertainty.
“The result follows from Erin’s burden, not from a finding that Alder Finch’s account is established,” the court stated.