The court identified permission as the sole material issue. Applying the supplied Rules 41 and 8, it said the State bore the burden of proving each required criminal element with reliable evidence; accusation or suspicion alone was insufficient.
Voss’s account established that Mercer left with the drill without paying and that she regarded it as merchandise. Her intention to sell it, however, did not by itself establish that she had not also agreed to lend it.
The earlier phone exchange contained an express request to borrow the drill for shelves until Saturday, followed by a positive but qualified response and a request that Mercer message before coming. Although Voss described her response as tentative, the record contained no further message explaining that it was not permission or withdrawing the proposed loan.
The pickup-day message said the drill was ready beside the counter. The court assessed it alongside the earlier exchange, finding it consistent with a contemplated loan and noting that it did not demand payment. The initial screenshot lacked the earlier conversation, but the fuller exchange was subsequently presented.
The evidence did not establish whether Mercer sent the requested advance message. The court declined to find either compliance or non-compliance, holding that this uncertainty could not be treated as proof against him or shift the burden onto him to establish permission.