The court treated the transaction record as reliable evidence that the transfer and deposit payment occurred. However, it did not explain what the spouses had agreed about allocating the expense. Presenting the same record repeatedly did not supply independent corroboration.
Clare’s account that she told Owen the deposit should come from his half was relevant, but lacked independent confirmation. Owen likewise neither produced his claimed proof of Clare’s instructions nor explained what those instructions said about whose share would fund the deposit.
The court accepted the distinction between permission to use savings and agreement to share a particular cost. Permission alone did not settle allocation, but identifying that distinction did not establish Clare’s entitlement to £1,200.
Under Rule 1 in the recorded judgment, Clare bore the burden of supporting the relief she sought with specific facts, records or testimony. Rule 2 gave greater weight to reliable records than vague or unsupported accounts, while allowing testimony to be considered. Rule 6 required the remedy to match the harm proved.
Applying those rules, the court found no sufficient connection between the amount claimed and an established entitlement or loss. Owen’s joint-account argument also failed to prove an agreement to share the deposit, but that failure did not discharge Clare’s burden.