The court identified two questions: whether Ibarra received clear notice that Bellara was the proposed destination, and whether he had a real chance to object before removal proceeded. It held that Ibarra had established both issues on the record before it.
The court gave weight to a September 28 detention call log showing that Ibarra made a six-minute call to his sister. According to the sister's account relayed in Ibarra's submissions, he said in Spanish that he had just learned he might be sent to Bellara and did not know how to object.
It also considered the English-only form and blank fear checkbox. While those materials did not establish every detail, the court found that, together with the call-log account, they supported Ibarra's position that he had not received notice in a form he understood well enough to act upon.
The court said it would not infer understanding merely because a paper form had been handed over. It found the agency's showing insufficient because the record did not clearly establish what the notice said, whether it was explained in a language Ibarra understood, or whether he had a meaningful opportunity to respond before the removal process advanced.
The court treated the call log as imperfect evidence of any staff conversation, but found it consistent with Ibarra's claimed confusion the following day. The outcome is limited to removal to Bellara and does not decide the merits of any underlying fear or protection claim.
“The court is not required to assume understanding from the mere handing over of a paper form.”