The accepted invoice established the ₹10,000 order price, the ₹4,000 advance, the ₹6,000 balance and a delivery deadline of 10 a.m. on 12 August 2025. The court noted that the invoice had been presented repeatedly, but those exhibits were copies of the same record rather than independent evidence.
The invoice did not prove timely delivery. The court accepted Bendre’s consistent account that the flyers arrived around 2 p.m., although there was no independent handover record. Kale’s final submission did not meaningfully rebut that account, while her earlier statement about non-arrival or non-receipt was too unclear to establish that the flyers had never been delivered.
Having found a four-hour delay, the court considered whether it justified withholding payment. It found no contractual term under which late delivery automatically cancelled the balance, no agreed reduction and no evidence establishing a particular financial loss.
Applying the recorded rules requiring evidence to support relief and a remedy to match proven harm, the court refused to calculate a discount without an evidentiary basis. The documented balance remained payable even though delivery had been late.
The fraud allegation also lacked specific supporting facts. The invoice showed an order and payment terms, not deception or self-dealing. The court found that the rule concerning loyalty by business partners or managers with entrusted authority did not apply because no such relationship or conduct had been established.