The court distinguished proof that Farid removed the drill from proof of his state of mind. Under the rules supplied for the proceeding, the prosecution had to establish each required element through reliable evidence; accusation or suspicion was insufficient.
Elaine’s presented account supported both the removal and her assertion that she had not given permission that evening. However, the court noted that repeated exhibits contained the same account, rather than separate independent observations, and that Elaine had not given admitted testimony beyond that presented account.
Nadia Rahman’s admitted eyewitness testimony independently supported the finding that Farid left Elaine’s shop area carrying a cordless drill. She had heard no discussion about permission and could not say whether the removal was authorised. Her evidence also did not support the suggestion that Farid tried to avoid being seen or heard.
A WhatsApp screenshot from 10 June showed an earlier authorised loan. The court treated it as context for Farid’s claimed belief, not proof of permission on 18 June. A later reply described by Farid was not produced and was not treated as verified evidence.
There was no evidence establishing whether Farid subsequently returned or kept the drill. The court also found that allegations of flight, personal use or an intention to keep it were not independently established. His earlier practice of asking before borrowing and the after-closing removal did not resolve the issue of dishonesty.
The court does not require Farid to prove that he had permission; the burden remains with the prosecution.