The signed incident-book entry carried meaningful weight as a record of the incident. It supported that the entrance had recently been mopped, Price slipped and bruised his knee, and a yellow warning sign was out. It also recorded Price’s immediate account that he had not seen a sign when entering.
However, the entry did not describe the sign’s location, the view from the doorway or the entrance layout. Repeated copies of that entry did not provide independent corroboration. References to a photograph likewise did not resolve visibility: no photograph exhibit or reliable detail establishing its timing and position was supplied.
Applying Rule 1, which placed the burden of supporting the claim on Price, and Rule 33, which required proof of duty, breach, causation and harm, the court found an essential evidential gap. The accident and bruise were established, but neither a failure to provide an effective warning nor a causal connection between such a failure and the injury was proved.
The phone evidence went no further than showing that Price held a phone. It did not establish that he was looking at its screen or that distraction contributed to the fall. There was therefore no basis under Rule 34 to reduce recovery for shared fault, but that did not cure the failure to prove negligence.
The court accepted the conditional agreement on £450. The absence of medical detail was not the decisive reason for dismissal; the claim failed on breach and causation.