The central evidentiary gap was the absence of the communications Brooks said linked the redesign to the extra price. The accepted quote was presented in evidence, but the messages were not. The court therefore could not assess their precise wording, timing or context.
Applying the recorded rules on proof, reliable records and business agreements, the court placed the burden on Brooks to establish the basis for payment. It distinguished the parties' arguments and accounts from evidence proving the asserted agreement. Repeated presentations of the same quote did not amount to separate corroboration.
The court did not require Nolan to repeat the $180 amount in a particular form to accept it. However, Brooks still had to show that the price had been communicated and accepted. Her description of the missing messages did not establish what Nolan understood when authorizing the work.
The quote also left the scope of the included revision unresolved. Although it expressly allowed one revision, it did not define when that allowance was exhausted. The hearing record lacked sufficient details about an earlier revision or the later changes to establish that the redesign exceeded the package.
Nolan's explanation was not independently verified, and the court did not conclusively find that the redesign was included. That uncertainty nevertheless could not supply the missing proof of an agreement to pay $180. Even proof of work beyond the package would not, by itself, establish acceptance of that particular price.
The court also rejected Brooks's reliance on the supplied business-loyalty rule. The record did not establish self-dealing or misuse of entrusted authority. Nor was there a basis for a reduced award, since no additional payment agreement or amount had been proved.