The court treated the accepted order as the strongest evidence of the original bargain. It recorded 300 menus, a $1,200 price, a $600 deposit and Friday delivery, while also noting the Saturday opening. It contained no term explaining whether revisions would extend the deadline.
Applying the recorded rule that business records define the deal, the court distinguished notice of a proposed change from agreement to it. Mercer’s account supported his position that Benton had been warned about Monday delivery, but he acknowledged that there was no express written acceptance. No message or other record establishing acceptance was presented.
The court did not decide whether the replacement file caused the delay. It found only that Mercer had not proved that the parties changed the written deadline.
The Monday receipt established delivery of all 300 menus. However, Benton’s signature under “received,” accompanied by a written objection to lateness and the balance, did not establish timely performance, settlement of the bill or later use of the menus.
On the amount claimed, the court applied the recorded requirement that the remedy match the harm and placed the burden of proof on Mercer. The price, deposit and completed delivery supported the possibility that some further amount might be owed, but did not establish entitlement to the entire unpaid balance after the missed deadline.
Neither side supplied evidence showing how many menus were used or what value they retained. That gap did not prove the menus were worthless, but it also prevented Mercer from establishing the full $600 sought.