The central evidence was a WhatsApp screenshot supplied by the defence. It showed Hessa asking Faris to bring back the power bank the next day, his agreement to do so after his shift, and her reminder that he had made the same promise the previous day.
The court found that the exchange supported an inference that Faris had the item when the messages were sent and that its return was expected. However, it did not establish how he obtained it, whether he had permission, or whether he acted dishonestly at that time. An agreement to return the item was not an admission of theft.
The judgment noted that the screenshot had no separate verification of authenticity or context. Even accepting its contents as accurately reproduced, its wording did not prove the disputed taking. Repeated presentation of the same screenshot did not add independent evidence.
The prosecution’s descriptions of Hessa’s complaint and denial of permission were submissions, rather than direct testimony from her or a produced complaint independently establishing those facts. Faris’s claim that she lent him the item was also unconfirmed, but he was not required to prove that explanation: the prosecution retained the burden of supporting each required criminal element with reliable evidence.
The return request failed on a separate evidentiary gap. The screenshot ended before any confirmation of a handover, and there was no direct testimony or other evidence showing the item’s current location. Hessa’s reported lack of possession did not establish that Faris still held it. Applying the recorded rule that relief must match what the evidence establishes, the court declined to order its return.