Elena said Graham left their rented Portland home after eleven years of marriage, leaving her with income insufficient to meet rent and basic bills. She said she worked reduced hours as a bookstore supervisor and believed Graham earned substantially more as a facilities coordinator.
She maintained that her permission extended to a rental deposit, not a $6,400 withdrawal or furniture purchases. She sought predictable temporary support and protection against further withdrawals before the divorce was resolved.
Graham said separate housing became necessary because living together had become untenable. He maintained that Elena told him to use savings to get settled and that the funds went toward setting up a modest Portland rental.
Responding to the judge’s request for messages or other evidence of an agreement, Graham said he could provide a text exchange about a deposit. He acknowledged that he had no message approving the full $6,400 and had transferred the money before sending an itemized explanation.
Graham also said his recent take-home pay included overtime that was no longer reliably available. He argued that Elena could work more hours and had overstated expenses he still partly paid, seeking limited support, no immediate repayment and continued access to savings for documented necessary expenses.