Under Rules 1 and 33 of the supplied rules, Akinwale bore the burden of proving the essential links between a duty of care, its breach, causation and harm. Recent mopping was established, but the evidence did not resolve whether the warning could be seen before she reached the wet floor.
A WhatsApp exchange, accepted as genuine, recorded Akinwale saying she had not seen a sign on entry. Adesina replied that the yellow sign was beside the entrance. The court considered these accounts relevant but found that the exchange did not independently establish visibility.
The photograph showed a yellow sign beside the entrance frame about ten minutes after the fall. Because it excluded most of the door, it did not establish an entering customer’s view at the relevant time. The court treated it neither as conclusive proof of visibility nor as evidence that the sign had been absent earlier.
Akinwale’s acknowledgment that she was looking towards the shelves made her account less certain, but did not prove that the sign was visible. Equally, Adesina’s assertion that nobody had previously fallen did not establish visibility on this occasion.
The injury evidence presented a separate gap. There was no description of the injury, treatment received, or other proof linking treatment to the fall. The court explained that medical records were not the only permissible evidence, but no alternative evidence supplied the necessary connection.
The court also declined to apportion fault under Rule 34, which permits a reduction where both sides contributed to an injury. That rule could not replace missing proof of breach or injury. It made no finding that Akinwale was careless merely because she had been looking towards the shelves.