The central evidentiary gap concerned responsibility for the cleaning, rather than whether Bellandi had incurred the expense. A bank transfer record established that he returned €720 of a €900 deposit and identified the remaining €180 as kitchen cleaning.
A paid invoice recorded cleaning of the oven and extractor filter at the flat two days after handover, at a cost of €180. The court accepted it as support that the work had been performed and paid for, but noted that it contained no photographs, assessment of the appliances’ condition or finding about who made the cleaning necessary.
Bellandi’s account that he found accumulated grease was consistent with the work described in the invoice. However, his submissions and attributed client statements were not independently verified documents or admitted witness testimony. The use of a professional cleaning service did not itself prove negligence.
Neri’s account of a handover message indicating that everything appeared satisfactory also carried limited weight. The message was not produced, and its timing and whether it followed an inspection inside the appliances could not be established. Its absence did not prove that the appliances were dirty, while the account of its wording did not prove that they were clean.
Applying the rules identified in the judgment, the court gave weight to reliable records and recognised that an itemized deduction tied to an actual cost had evidentiary support. But proof of spending was not conclusive proof of responsibility. Under Rule 1, Neri bore the burden of supporting her request for repayment, so the unresolved issue fell against her.
The court decided the matter on the available record after both parties had a final opportunity to address the evidence. No further obtainable proof was identified, and an adjournment was not allowed.