Azevedo said she agreed to pay R$10,000 for a counter, shelves and four doors, paid R$8,000 by Pix, and expected installation by May 8 before her café opened on May 10. She acknowledged requesting a wider opening for her coffee machine but disputed that this amounted to accepting delivery after opening day.
She said the fittings arrived on May 14 without the doors and that her signature on the delivery sheet acknowledged arrival rather than completion. She sought R$1,800 for shelf completion and R$1,200 for temporary counter rental, while acknowledging that the quote and receipt did not by themselves establish entitlement to every amount claimed.
Nogueira said the change was requested after cutting had begun and that a WhatsApp response indicated acceptance of extra time. He acknowledged that the quotation listed May 8 and that he never supplied a firm replacement date.
He also acknowledged that the four doors were unfinished and not separately listed on the signed installation sheet. He opposed repayment, relying on delivery of the counter and shelving, their continued use and his offer to return. He maintained that R$2,000 remained payable but brought no separate counterclaim.