The court treated the readable quotation and deposit entry, accepted by both parties, as the strongest evidence of the transaction. Those records listed 100 menus for PHP 8,000, a PHP 4,000 deposit received, and Friday delivery. They established the price and payment terms but did not independently prove delivery.
The Messenger screenshot showed that Dacalos communicated her opening-time concern in advance and Cabigas acknowledged it. However, his reply did not clearly promise delivery before 9 a.m. The court also noted that repeated exhibit entries described the same exchange, rather than separate corroborating messages.
Cabigas’s account that he delivered on Friday afternoon was relayed through counsel. The court did not treat it as independently verified delivery evidence or admitted witness testimony, and the precise arrival time remained uncertain.
That uncertainty did not establish delivery after Friday, non-delivery, or breach of a proven before-9 deadline. Dacalos acknowledged that she had no further proof of arrival time or a specific loss.
Applying the evidentiary and remedial rules identified in the judgment, the court required support for an additional contractual term and a fair basis for withholding payment. Any reduction also had to correspond to proven harm. It found neither a changed deadline nor an evidentiary basis for a deduction.
The court expressly distinguished Dacalos’s advance notice from proof of a contractual change. It also explained that it was not requiring her to disprove the claim: Cabigas had established the price, deposit and unpaid balance, while no proven failure justified withholding payment.