The court applied the supplied theft rule requiring proof of both unauthorized control and a purpose to deprive the owner. The supplied definition of deprivation covered permanent withholding, withholding that appropriates a substantial portion of the property's value or use, and other specified forms of appropriation.
A camera still showed Mercer leaving the shop with a drill case at 6:12 p.m., a taking he did not dispute. However, the image had no audio and showed no earlier conversation. It could not establish permission, the identity of the drill or Mercer's intent.
The checkout sheet contained no entry for Mercer or the drill. Witness Mara Voss confirmed that absence but could not explain it and had not witnessed the request, taking, return or any conversation about the loan. The court treated the sheet as evidence of an unrecorded loan, not proof that permission had never been given or that Mercer knew an entry was missing.
The phone exchange supported an overnight loan subject to conditions: use of the spare drill, a book entry and return before opening. It did not identify the drill taken, establish Nolan Price's authority or show whether an entry had been made elsewhere. Those uncertainties did not establish knowing conduct outside the scope of consent.
The drill was returned at 10:20 a.m., after the requested deadline. But the record did not establish how long after opening that was or any substantial loss of use. The court also found no established disposal of the drill or demand for consideration for its return.
The court did not accept oversleeping or the absence of business loss as independently proved. Those evidentiary gaps, it held, did not shift the prosecution's burden to Mercer.
“A failure to meet a return time, without more, does not establish the statutory purpose to deprive beyond a reasonable doubt,” the court held.