The court distinguished evidence of the advertisement’s content from evidence of its funding. The recording established that an advertisement aired in Washington, D.C., on October 6 and contained presidential praise alongside a government-service information link. It did not identify who paid for that airing.
The Office’s October 5 announcement said future advertisements would move to outside funding that week. But it supplied no exact cutoff date, did not establish that existing bookings had been canceled and said the Lang Public Leadership Fund would not reimburse costs of advertisements already aired.
The court treated the announcement as evidence of a planned transition, rather than proof of either public or private payment for the October 6 broadcast. Neither payment records nor witness testimony identified its payer, and no specific future publicly funded booking was shown.
Applying the recorded rules requiring specific facts, records or testimony, the court held that questions about the funding transition could not substitute for proof. It also found that the advertisement was not shown to consist only of presidential promotion.
The request for a cutoff date lacked a supporting basis in the rules or evidence. The court reasoned that relief must correspond to the harm established, rather than extend to broader assurances unsupported by the record.
“But uncertainty on the defendant’s side does not establish the plaintiff’s claim,” the court stated.