The central question was whether the training was expected or required work despite the attendance sheet’s optional label. Bennett bore the burden of supporting her claim with specific facts or records.
The signed attendance sheet established that Bennett attended the Kingston shop’s stock-system session from 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. Both parties accepted the copy, which recorded her arrival and departure signatures. However, the court noted that the sheet did not establish what staff had been told separately.
The manager’s message supplied that missing context. When Bennett asked whether she could skip the session because the sheet described it as optional, Colin told her that she needed the training before her next till shift and asked her to attend from 9 to 1. Copper Finch confirmed that he sent the message and that it directed her attendance.
The court gave that specific instruction greater weight than the general heading. It found the message reliable evidence that attendance was expected as part of Bennett’s work, rather than relying on her submissions alone.
On payment, the timesheet and matching pay statement showed that Bennett’s submitted shop hours were paid at CAD 20 an hour, but omitted the training. Copper Finch had no separate record of payment for the session and identified no different rate.
The court acknowledged that the manager’s message did not expressly promise payment. Nevertheless, applying the supplied pay-claim rule—which required consideration of what was earned, paid, withheld and documented—it held that the combined evidence supported four unpaid hours at CAD 20 an hour.