The court identified two questions: whether the scheduled sessions were paid work or unpaid observation, and whether Caldwell had proved the exact amount claimed. It treated a text message from Harbor & Pine manager Colin Reese as the key exhibit, accepting it as sufficiently authentic because it was a written manager message on which both sides relied.
The message stated: “Come in Tues, Wed, Thurs 8-noon for training. Wear dark pants. We will start you on register and drink station.” The court found that the fixed schedule and assigned register and drink-station duties were strong evidence of required, work-like training rather than a casual invitation to observe.
Although the message did not expressly state that the training would be paid, the court held that Caldwell had met her burden on the central issue of whether she had been directed to undertake work-like tasks. It found the written message more reliable than the parties’ competing descriptions and said it supported Caldwell’s account better than Harbor & Pine’s denial.
However, the court applied the requirement that a wage claim be supported by clear accounting. It found Caldwell’s assertion of 12 hours plausible but insufficient to prove the precise $240 sum without evidence of a pay rate, payroll records or other calculation. The court therefore accepted liability in principle but limited relief to an unspecified proven amount.
“It is not a casual invitation to watch.”