The Commission treated the published roster for the following fortnight as the central exhibit. It showed Wallace listed for Saturday and Sunday shifts which were later crossed out and marked “cover arranged”. The Commission found that the document proved that upcoming shifts had been shown and later changed, but did not itself establish the reason for the change.
While the timing of the roster alteration after the wage message created suspicion, the Commission held that timing alone did not prove retaliation. The café’s explanation that the changes reflected casual scheduling and coverage needs was consistent with the roster notation, and no separate decision record, policy document or witness account was produced to show that the wage complaint caused the change.
The Commission said Wallace bore the burden of proving facts supporting relief. It found the evidence did not show that the shift had been promised in a way that made its removal unlawful, nor did it establish entitlement to broader economic loss, future loss or an injunction.
The formal judgment stated: “The plaintiff proved a specific claimed amount, but did not prove the key causal link needed for retaliation or improper removal from work.”
“The roster screenshot helps Erin in one respect: it shows she was expected to work and that the roster changed after her wage complaint. But suspicion is not proof.”