The central exhibit was a deduction notice identifying a $240 garage shelf replacement charge. The court found that it reliably established the item and amount Pruitt listed, but did not explain when or how the damage occurred or identify anything Mercer had done to cause it. Repeated presentations of the same notice added no independent support.
The court accepted that Mercer reported sagging four days after moving in because both parties acknowledged the report. However, no copy of the text was presented as an exhibit. The early report established that she raised the problem promptly, not the shelf's original condition or the cause of its failure.
Neither side presented independent evidence of the shelf's condition. There was no photograph, repair record, receipt or other direct evidence of cause or cost before the court.
Applying the supplied rules, the court distinguished Mercer's burden to support her request from Pruitt's need to justify retaining the deduction. Rule 1 did not permit the court to treat her allegation of a pre-existing defect as proven merely because she reported sagging. But that evidentiary gap did not establish that Pruitt could keep the money.
Rule 9 distinguished ordinary wear from negligent or intentional damage, and the evidence did not establish which had occurred. Rule 11 called for an itemized deduction tied to actual costs, while Rules 2 and 30 directed attention to reliable proof of condition, cause and repair cost. The notice alone did not meet those evidentiary needs.